Strategy Arena

Charlie Scalper ranks first on the full completed-position record with a 0.98 profit factor and -$0.56 per position. 0 of 3 mature records have an average result whose 95% range stays above zero. Crazy Bot's revised logic began on 7 September 2026. Its new record is still empty, so no result is claimed yet.

This page checks which practice engine made or lost money, how painful the path was, whether the average result is distinguishable from zero and which coins created the result. Partial exits are joined first, and open positions are never counted as wins.

THE RECORD
SETS THE RANK
the longest bright line is not always the most reliable one
Crazy Bot logic revision7 Sep 2026New results kept separate
Crazy Bot · revised positions0No verdict before a mature record
Crazy Bot · revised net$0.00After paper fees and fill allowance
Crazy Bot · revised return+0.0%From $2.4k at revision
Crazy Bot · revised average trade$0.00After paper costs
Crazy Bot · revised profit factorNot readyGross wins divided by gross losses
Crazy Bot · revised deepest fallNot readyNew record only
Crazy Bot · revised verdictToo earlyNeeds 200 positions and eight weeks
Charlie Scalper · completed positions747Partial exits joined first
Charlie Scalper · net result-$421.91-4.2%
Charlie Scalper · profit factor0.98Gross wins / gross losses
Charlie Scalper · average per position-$0.5668% winners
Crazy Bot · completed positions1,400Partial exits joined first
Crazy Bot · net result-$9.2k-92.2%
Crazy Bot · profit factor0.87Gross wins / gross losses
Crazy Bot · average per position-$6.5939% winners
Shadow Bot · completed positions135Partial exits joined first
Shadow Bot · net result-$820.53-8.2%
Shadow Bot · profit factor0.87Gross wins / gross losses
Shadow Bot · average per position-$6.0836% winners
Total completed positions2,282Partial exits are not extra trades
Combined net result-$10.5kNot a shared account
Mature records3 of 3At least 30 positions
Mature records with positive range0 of 395% resampled range above zero

Ask this page.

Choose a useful question or type your own. The answer and chart use only the figures already checked for this page.

Choose a question to build a chart.

Current viewWaiting for a question

The chart will appear here.

Crazy Bot starts a clean second record

The logic changed on 7 September 2026. Earlier positions stay in the full history, while every revised position is counted separately after a trading-cost allowance. The new version gets no credit from the old one.

Earlier Crazy Bot record-$9.2k
Revised record$0.00

Crazy Bot's revised logic began on 7 September 2026. Its new record is still empty, so no result is claimed yet.

The record, not the bot name

Every engine is judged on fully closed practice positions. Profit-taking pieces are joined before the win rate, average and uncertainty are calculated.

Practice enginePositionsNet resultReturnWinnersProfit factorAverage positionDeepest fallLikely average rangeShuffled paths matching
Charlie Scalper747-$421.91-4.2%67.6%0.98-$0.56-21.7%-$5.39 to $4.152.9%
Crazy Bot1400-$9.2k-92.2%39.1%0.87-$6.59-99.8%-$13.12 to -$0.148.3%
Shadow Bot135-$820.53-8.2%36.3%0.87-$6.08-12.2%-$22.52 to $9.8716.9%

Charlie Scalper ranks first on the full completed-position record with a 0.98 profit factor and -$0.56 per position. 0 of 3 mature records have an average result whose 95% range stays above zero. Crazy Bot's revised logic began on 7 September 2026. Its new record is still empty, so no result is claimed yet.

Where did the result come from?

Coin-level results are shown for diagnosis. A tiny group is evidence to investigate, not a ready-made rule.

Crazy Bot · LABUSDT$930.14
Crazy Bot · RIFUSDT$716.05
Crazy Bot · SLXUSDT$673.88
Crazy Bot · BEATUSDT$671.28
Crazy Bot · TUTUSDT$647.31
Crazy Bot · 龙虾USDT$619.52
Shadow Bot · TUTUSDT$593.61
Crazy Bot · MANAUSDT$583.30
Crazy Bot · BELUSDT$580.68
Crazy Bot · SQDUSDT$572.57
Crazy Bot · BASEDUSDT$567.76
Crazy Bot · BICOUSDT$552.23

Research by for Charlie Quant Lab · Updated